The right way to lose weight, explained by a doctor (Part 1): how efficient weight loss works and the basics

  • Published:
  • Updated:
  • Written by the Hiro Clinic Medical Weight Loss editorial team
  • 47 min read
Medically reviewed by Dr. Hiroko Oka Reviewed byDr. Hiroko OkaCertified Member, Japanese Society of Internal Medicine Editorial policy
The right way to lose weight, explained by a doctor (Part 1): how efficient weight loss works and the basics

In recent years, a huge amount of diet information has been shared through social media and the internet. However, the reality is that extreme dietary restrictions and methods driven by passing trends carry a high risk of harming your health and rarely lead to long-term success. In this article, a doctor explains the “right way to diet,” based on scientific evidence and experience in clinical practice. We cover practical points for aiming safely and effectively for your ideal figure from three angles: nutrition, exercise and lifestyle habits.

The short answerIf you are busy, just read this

  • The key to successful weight loss is a mindset that puts improving your health first, not the number on the scale
  • The basic principle of the diet doctors recommend is not to cut something out drastically, but to get the nutrients you need in the right amounts
  • Exercise is essential for successful weight loss and for preventing rebound weight gain

The key to successful weight loss is a “health first” mindset

The key to successful weight loss is a mindset that puts improving your health first, not the number on the scale. Weight loss that sacrifices health may change your appearance temporarily, but in the long run it can cause serious problems such as feeling unwell, a slower metabolism and hormonal imbalance.

1-1. Risks of rapid weight loss

Extreme dietary restriction and rapid weight loss over a short period lead to a loss of muscle mass. Muscle accounts for a large part of your basal metabolism, so the more muscle you lose, the more your body becomes “hard to slim down.” In addition, extreme calorie restriction activates a “starvation switch” in the body, putting it into an energy-saving mode that tries to sustain itself on less energy. As a result, the rate of rebound weight gain after weight loss increases.

On social media, we often see people worried that “my weight went down, but I don’t look any different.” Many also say, “my weight was dropping steadily, but when I look in the mirror I don’t look any more toned.” If you trust only the number on the scale and continue restricting calories, it is hard to notice “hidden muscle loss,” where you are actually losing muscle rather than fat. I, too, often hear similar concerns from patients in clinical practice.

Vitamin and mineral deficiencies also have negative effects on appearance and quality of life, such as weakened immunity, anemia, skin problems and hair loss. Harming your health in pursuit of short-term results defeats the purpose.

1-2. Focus on a “healthy weight” rather than an “ideal weight”

In medical practice, we emphasize comprehensive health indicators that include not just BMI, but also visceral fat, muscle mass and blood test results.
For example, even someone with a model-like figure faces a higher risk of irregular periods and osteoporosis if they are undernourished due to extreme dietary restriction. On the other hand, a person whose BMI is slightly above standard but who has good muscle mass and normal blood sugar and blood pressure is assessed as having a “healthy body type.”

Key point

In other words, what you should aim for is not “an ideal image seen in magazines or on social media,” but a healthy weight that suits your lifestyle and genetic constitution.

1-3. Dieting is part of “improving lifestyle habits”

The right way to diet is not just a “weight-loss program” but a project to improve your overall quality of life.
To do this, the following perspectives are essential.

Improving the quality of your diet

Balancing your nutrition also improves immunity and concentration.

Building an exercise habit

Maintaining muscle mass and improving posture and stamina raises your performance in daily life.

Improving sleep quality

Lack of sleep disrupts the balance of hormones that control appetite, leading to overeating.

Stress management

Excessive stress can cause binge eating and drinking and hormonal problems.

Instead of thinking of dieting as “a series of endurance and restrictions,” seeing it as “a process of building healthy, comfortable lifestyle habits” helps you keep it up without strain.

1-4. Safe rate of weight loss recommended by doctors

To lose weight without harming your health, losing no more than 3–5% of your body weight per month is considered desirable. This is a pace that reduces mainly fat without drastically reducing muscle or water.
For example, for a person weighing 60 kg, losing about 1.8–3 kg per month is ideal. At this pace, there are fewer negative effects on hormones and metabolism, and the risk of rebound is also reduced.

1-5. Changes in appearance come later

With the right diet, even if your weight changes only slightly in the first few weeks, improvements in muscle mass and metabolism and stabilization of blood sugar are steadily progressing inside your body. These changes appear in your figure over time, and also affect your skin and how bright you look.
In other words, you are more likely to succeed if you use health indicators and everyday comfort as motivation rather than chasing numbers alone.

Key points

  • The goal of dieting is “better health,” not “weight loss”
  • Rapid weight loss risks a slower metabolism, rebound and nutritional deficiencies
  • A healthy weight considers blood tests and muscle mass, not just BMI
  • Improving your lifestyle habits as a whole is the key to success
  • A weight-loss pace of no more than 3–5% per month is ideal
Woman standing on a scale

The “balanced nutrition” diet recommended by doctors

The basic principle of the diet doctors recommend is not to cut something out drastically, but to get the nutrients you need in the right amounts. Food is the most important element of the right way to diet. It is difficult to lose weight through exercise alone, and without well-balanced meals you can neither maintain muscle mass nor look after your health.

2-1. The golden balance of the three macronutrients

As a guide for nutrient distribution while dieting, referring to the “Dietary Reference Intakes for Japanese” from Japan’s Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare and international guidelines, aim for 50–60% carbohydrates, 20–25% protein and 20–25% fat.

Carbohydrates (sugars)

The main source of energy. Focus on low-GI foods such as whole grains, brown rice, oatmeal and multigrain rice.

Protein

The building material for muscles, organs, hormones, immune cells and more. Aim for 1.0–1.2 g per kg of body weight, with a good balance of meat, fish, eggs and soy products.

Fat

Essential for cell membranes and hormone production. Choose good-quality fats such as olive oil, flaxseed oil, EPA/DHA from oily fish, and nuts.

Key point

Keeping to this balance makes it possible to reduce only fat without lowering your basal metabolism.

2-2. The pitfalls of excessive carbohydrate restriction

The idea that “you’ll lose weight quickly if you cut carbs” sounds appealing, but cutting carbohydrates drastically is dangerous. Carbohydrates are the main energy source for the brain and nervous system, and restricting them completely can cause problems such as the following.

  • Reduced concentration and judgment
  • Severe fatigue and drowsiness
  • Hormonal imbalance (such as irregular periods)
  • Increased burden on protein and fat metabolism

From a doctor’s standpoint, we recommend an approach of “optimizing the quality and amount of carbohydrates” rather than “carbohydrate restriction.” For example, simply improving quality, such as replacing white rice with brown or multigrain rice, or switching from sweet buns to whole-grain bread, improves blood sugar control.

2-3. Protein is the guardian of muscle and metabolism

To maintain muscle mass while dieting, you need enough protein.
Without enough, muscle breaks down, basal metabolism drops and the risk of rebound increases.

Recommended foods

  • Chicken breast and tenderloin (low fat, high protein)
  • Fish (oily fish such as mackerel, salmon and sardines are also rich in EPA/DHA)
  • Eggs (contain a good balance of essential amino acids)
  • Tofu, natto and soy milk (plant protein)
  • Greek yogurt (high protein, low sugar)

Tips for getting enough

  • Include at least one protein source at every meal
  • Including protein at breakfast raises your metabolism for the day

2-4. Good-quality fats regulate hormones and metabolism

The misconception that fat = weight gain is deep-rooted, but fat is essential for life. In women in particular, a lack of fat disrupts hormone production and can cause irregular periods and skin problems.

Recommended sources of fat

  • Olive oil and avocado (oleic acid)
  • Flaxseed oil and chia seeds (alpha-linolenic acid)
  • Oily fish (EPA, DHA)
  • Nuts (also rich in vitamin E)

Ideally, avoid trans fats (common in margarine and processed foods) and oxidized oils (reused frying oil), and use olive oil for cooking with heat and flaxseed or perilla oil for unheated dishes.

2-5. The importance of vitamins, minerals and dietary fiber

In addition to a good balance of the three macronutrients, vitamins and minerals are also essential for successful weight loss.

  • B vitamins: help metabolize carbohydrates, fats and proteins (pork, brown rice, eggs)
  • Iron: prevents anemia and supports metabolism (lean red meat, hijiki seaweed, spinach)
  • Calcium: keeps bones and teeth healthy (dairy products, small fish, tofu)
  • Magnesium: supports energy metabolism and nerve stability (nuts, seaweed)
  • Dietary fiber: curbs blood sugar spikes and improves gut health (vegetables, seaweed, mushrooms, mixed grains)

Including colorful vegetables and fruits naturally provides vitamins and minerals.

2-6. Meal timing and blood sugar control

Meal times and intervals also affect the success of a diet.
Doctors recommend “three meals a day plus snacks as needed.”

Breakfast

Switches on your metabolism for the day. Protein plus complex carbohydrates is ideal.

Lunch

Provides energy and stabilizes blood sugar. Keep it balanced.

Dinner

Eat at least 3 hours before bed, keeping fats and carbohydrates moderate.

Snacks

Low-GI, high-protein foods such as nuts, yogurt and boiled eggs.

As a result, sharp rises and falls in blood sugar are curbed, making it easier to prevent fat accumulation.

2-7. Sample daily meal plan recommended by a doctor (1,600 kcal)

Breakfast

  • 1 slice of whole-grain bread
  • 2 boiled eggs
  • Salad (olive oil + vinegar)
  • Yogurt + blueberries

Lunch

  • 100 g brown rice
  • Sautéed chicken breast
  • Spinach with sesame dressing
  • Miso soup (wakame seaweed, tofu)

Dinner

  • Steamed white fish (with vegetables)
  • 80 g multigrain rice
  • Steamed vegetables (broccoli, carrot)
  • A small amount of kimchi

Key points

  • Nutritional balance: 50–60% carbohydrates, 20–25% protein, 20–25% fat
  • The key to carb restriction is “optimizing” by reviewing quality and quantity
  • Get protein at every meal and eat good-quality fats in moderation
  • Vitamins, minerals and dietary fiber are essential for metabolism and health
  • Stabilize blood sugar through meal timing and smart snacking

Not sure if it suits you? Start with a consultation.

A doctor decides whether you can use it and which dose is appropriate, based on your consultation and questionnaire.

No consultation fee (first & follow-up visits)Online consultation available

Building an exercise habit: combining strength training and aerobic exercise

Exercise is essential for successful weight loss and for preventing rebound weight gain. We are often asked, “Is exercise really necessary?” Dietary restriction alone can reduce weight in the short term, but much of that comes from losing muscle and water, which lowers your basal metabolism. Combining it with exercise allows you to lose fat while maintaining or increasing muscle mass, building a body that is less prone to rebound.

Doctors recommend a hybrid of strength training (anaerobic exercise) and aerobic exercise. This combination is excellent for both burning fat and maintaining metabolism.

3-1. The role and effects of strength training (anaerobic exercise)

Strength training is the foundation of weight loss. Muscle accounts for most of your basal metabolism and burns energy even at rest. As muscle mass increases, the calories you burn each day naturally rise, giving you a “body that gains weight less easily and loses it more easily.” On social media, many people say that “you notice weight changes more with aerobic exercise, but strength training does more to change your body,” which matches what we see in clinical practice. Be careful: relying only on dietary restriction and aerobic exercise makes it easy to lose muscle as well.

Main benefits of strength training

  • Higher basal metabolism
  • Better posture (improving a hunched back or arched lower back)
  • Maintaining and improving bone density (especially preventing osteoporosis in women)
  • Fat burning and beauty benefits through increased growth hormone secretion
  • Better blood sugar control (diabetes prevention)

Recommended frequency and duration

  • 2–3 times a week (not on consecutive days; leave 48 hours between sessions)
  • About 20–40 minutes per session

Sample full-body routine for beginners (bodyweight training)

Squats

3 sets of 15 reps

(Strengthens lower body and core)

Push-ups

3 sets of 10 reps

(Chest, shoulders, arms)

Plank

3 sets of 30 seconds

(Core)

Hip lifts

3 sets of 15 reps

(Buttocks, back)

*Once you get used to it, dumbbells or resistance bands make it easy to adjust the load.

3-2. The role and effects of aerobic exercise

Aerobic exercise promotes fat burning while improving cardiopulmonary function. Raising your basal metabolism with strength training and burning fat directly with aerobic exercise makes for efficient weight loss.

Main benefits of aerobic exercise

  • Fat burning (especially visceral fat)
  • Improved cardiopulmonary function
  • Stress relief (promotes serotonin secretion)
  • Stabilizes blood pressure and blood sugar

Recommended activities

  • Walking (especially brisk walking)
  • Jogging
  • Cycling
  • Swimming and water walking
  • Dance and aerobics

Recommended frequency and duration

  • 3–5 times a week
  • 20–40 minutes per session (the fat-burning effect really kicks in after about 20 minutes)

3-3. Combining strength training and aerobic exercise effectively

The order of exercise changes its effect. From the viewpoint of doctors and exercise physiology, the order strength training → aerobic exercise is recommended.

Why:

  • Strength training uses up carbohydrates → fat burning speeds up during the aerobic exercise that follows
  • Growth hormone secretion supports fat breakdown during aerobic exercise

Example:

  1. Strength training (full body, 20 minutes)

  2. Aerobic exercise (walking or exercise bike, 30 minutes)

3-4. Making use of NEAT (non-exercise activity thermogenesis)

Even people who “don’t have time to go to the gym” can increase the calories they burn in daily life. This is called NEAT (Non-Exercise Activity Thermogenesis).

Ways to increase NEAT

  • Take the stairs instead of the elevator
  • Walk one station’s distance when commuting or shopping
  • Stand up frequently during desk work
  • Do cleaning and laundry thoroughly

Key point

Over the long term, these everyday movements add up to an effect comparable to exercising at the gym.

3-5. Managing motivation to keep going

The most important point in making exercise a habit is “not overdoing it.”

  • Set small goals (start with 1–2 times a week, 10 minutes at a time)
  • Visualize your exercise days on a calendar or in an app
  • Exercise while listening to music or watching videos you enjoy
  • Measure your body fat percentage and waist size, not just your weight

Exercising with friends or family also improves your chances of keeping it up.

◎Key points

  • Combining strength training and aerobic exercise is essential for successful weight loss
  • Strength training raises basal metabolism and prevents rebound
  • Aerobic exercise is effective for burning fat and strengthening cardiopulmonary function
  • The best order is strength training → aerobic exercise
  • Increasing everyday NEAT raises calorie burn without strain

Part 1 summary and what’s coming next

What we have covered so far is the “health first” mindset that forms the foundation of successful weight loss, along with the basic strategies for diet and exercise. Rather than fixating only on numbers, improving your physical condition and overall quality of life is what leads to long-term success.

That’s the end of Part 1. In Part 2, we explain “sleep and stress management,” “medical weight loss options” and “the right mindset for keeping it up” in more detail.

About self-pay treatment and off-label use

Self-pay treatment
Medical weight loss is self-pay treatment (paid in full by the patient) and is not covered by public health insurance.
Off-label use
Using medicines for weight management or weight loss may be off-label use, outside the indications approved in Japan.
Relief System for Adverse Drug Reactions
With off-label use, health damage such as a serious side effect may not be covered by Japan’s Relief System for Adverse Drug Reactions.
Individual differences and the doctor’s judgment
Effects and side effects vary from person to person. A doctor decides after a consultation whether you can use a medicine and which medicine and dose are appropriate. Please tell us in advance about any symptoms, chronic conditions or medicines you are taking.

FAQ

Here are answers to questions readers often ask about the right way to diet. Use them together with Part 2 to plan weight loss you can manage comfortably.

QWhat rate of healthy weight loss do doctors recommend?
A

The guideline is to lose no more than 3–5% of your body weight per month. For someone weighing 60 kg, that is a pace of about 1.8–3 kg per month. Because this mainly reduces fat without losing much muscle or water, there are fewer negative effects on hormones and metabolism, and the risk of rebound is also reduced.

QIs a diet that cuts out carbohydrates completely bad for you?
A

Extreme carbohydrate restriction may cause reduced concentration and judgment, severe fatigue, and hormonal imbalance such as irregular periods. From a doctor’s standpoint, rather than “cutting out carbs,” we recommend an approach that optimizes the quality and amount of carbohydrates, such as replacing white rice with brown or multigrain rice.

QHow much protein should I eat?
A

The recommendation is about 1.0–1.2 g per kg of body weight, with a good balance from meat, fish, eggs and soy products. Without enough, muscle breaks down, basal metabolism drops and the risk of rebound increases, so the key is to include at least one protein source at every meal.

QHow often should I exercise?
A

As a guide, do strength training 2–3 times a week (leaving at least 48 hours between sessions) for about 20–40 minutes each time. Combining this with aerobic exercise 3–5 times a week for about 20–40 minutes each time makes it easier to both burn fat and maintain basal metabolism. Doing aerobic exercise after strength training is said to make fat burning more efficient.

QWhat should I do if I’m too busy to make time for exercise?
A

We recommend paying attention to NEAT (non-exercise activity thermogenesis). Simply increasing everyday movement, such as taking the stairs instead of the elevator, walking one station’s distance when commuting or shopping, and standing up frequently during desk work, lets you build up the calories you burn.

Not sure? Talk to us

No consultation fee (first & follow-up visits)Online consultation available

Toll-free 0120-241-929 (toll-free in Japan, 9:00–18:00 JST, Japanese only)

See prices

Medically reviewed by: Dr. Hiroko Oka (Chairman, Medical Corporation Fukubikai / Certified Member, Japanese Society of Internal Medicine)

Reviewing doctor: Hiroko Oka
Reviewing doctor

Hiroko OkaDirector, Hiro Clinic Kawaguchi (physician)

Japanese Society of Internal Medicine About our medical review and editorial policy

You may also like

Back to all articles

Ask our AI chat AI chat