How to choose medical weight loss that suits your constitution | A doctor explains the best way for you to lose weight

  • Published:
  • Updated:
  • Written by the Hiro Clinic Medical Weight Loss editorial team
  • 39 min read
Medically reviewed by Dr. Hiroko Oka Reviewed byDr. Hiroko OkaCertified Member, Japanese Society of Internal Medicine Editorial policy
How to choose medical weight loss that suits your constitution | A doctor explains the best way for you to lose weight

To keep up a diet without strain, the shortest route is to understand your constitution and choose a method that suits you. Dieting is not simply “an effort to lose weight”; it is an ongoing habit of identifying the method that suits you and maintaining your physical and mental health.
Recently, “choosing a method that matches your constitution” has been attracting particular attention. The reason the same dietary restriction or exercise works for some people and not for others is that several factors come into play, such as each person’s metabolism, hormone function and gut environment.

In this article, we explain from a specialist’s perspective how to choose a diet you can keep up without strain, based on your constitution.

When consulting with patients, I often hear, “My friend lost weight on the same diet, but nothing changed for me.” On social media, too, there are posts saying “the diet that suits you is best” (@makki_linola), showing how much interest there is in differences in constitution.

The short answerIf you are busy, just read this

  • To keep up a diet without strain, the shortest route is to choose a method that suits you after understanding your constitution
  • To understand your constitution, it is useful to check your tendencies from three perspectives: basal metabolism, how you metabolize carbohydrates and fats, and hormonal balance
  • Understanding your constitution and choosing a method that suits you is the most reliable shortcut to a successful diet you can keep up without strain

What you will learn in this article

  • Why differences in constitution affect diet results
  • Steps to understand your constitution, such as basal metabolism, carbohydrate metabolism and hormonal balance
  • Recommended diet and exercise methods for each constitution type
  • Practical points for keeping it up without strain

Results vary from person to person, so if you have any health concerns, do not rely on your own judgment; consult a doctor.

Why diets tailored to your constitution matter

“Constitution” refers to the way your body tends to respond, shaped by the traits you were born with and your lifestyle habits. Choosing a method that ignores these differences in constitution is a major reason why diets are hard to keep up and fail to produce results.

Examples:

  • High / low basal metabolism
  • More / less muscle mass
  • Good / poor at metabolizing carbohydrates
  • Large / small changes in appetite due to stress

Even with the same calorie restriction, the effect and burden vary greatly depending on constitution. In that sense, it can be said that there is no “diet that works for everyone.”

Steps to assess your constitution for a successful diet

To understand your constitution, it is useful to check your tendencies from three perspectives: basal metabolism, how you metabolize carbohydrates and fats, and hormonal balance. Even without special tests, you can get a rough idea of your tendencies from body composition monitor readings and your usual changes in physical condition.

1. Understanding your basal metabolism

Basal metabolism is “the energy you burn even when doing nothing.”
A body composition monitor can measure your muscle mass and estimated metabolic rate.

Key point
People with a low basal metabolism are more likely to see their metabolism drop further with sudden calorie restriction.

2. How you metabolize carbohydrates and fats

Even with the same calorie intake, people who are poor at metabolizing carbohydrates tend to develop insulin resistance more easily and accumulate fat more readily.
It is also possible to learn your tendencies through blood tests or a glucose tolerance test.

Evidence
Ludwig DS. “The glycemic index: physiological mechanisms relating to obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease.” JAMA. 2002 May 8;287(18):2414-23.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11988062/

3. Hormonal balance

In women in particular, estrogen and progesterone affect body fat distribution and water retention.
Hormonal balance fluctuates greatly during menopause and after childbirth, so measures that take these characteristics into account are needed.

Recommended diets by constitution

The methods that are easiest to keep up differ across four types: low metabolism, poor carbohydrate metabolism, low muscle mass, and prone to stress-related weight gain. Below, we introduce the features of each type and recommended approaches.

A. Low-metabolism type

Features

  • Sensitivity to cold
  • Prone to swelling
  • Tire easily with dietary restriction

Recommended

  • Increase muscle mass with strength training
  • Keep warm to boost metabolism (warm water, baths)
  • Avoid excessive carbohydrate restriction

Reference study
Speakman JR, Selman C. “Physical activity and resting metabolic rate.” Proc Nutr Soc. 2003 May;62(2):621-34.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14692602/

B. Poor carbohydrate metabolism type

Features

  • Can’t give up sweets
  • Get sleepy after meals
  • Tend to gain fat around the belly

Recommended

  • Meals centered on low-GI foods
  • Eat more dietary fiber
  • Introduce carbohydrate restriction gradually

C. Low-muscle-mass type

Features

  • Light in weight but not toned
  • Posture tends to slump
  • No exercise habit

Recommended

  • Continue strength training 2–3 times a week
  • Eat 1.2–1.5 g of protein per kg of body weight
  • Do aerobic exercise after strength training

D. Prone to stress-related weight gain

Features

  • Overeat when irritated
  • Lack of sleep
  • Autonomic nervous system easily thrown off balance

Recommended

  • Keep a food diary and link it to your emotions
  • Breathing techniques and mindfulness
  • Get at least 7 hours of sleep

Reference study
Torres SJ, Nowson CA. “Relationship between stress, eating behavior, and obesity.” Nutrition. 2007 Nov-Dec;23(11-12):887-94.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17869482/

Practical points for keeping up your diet

Even if you choose a method that suits your constitution, it will not lead to results unless you can keep it up. Keeping four practical points in mind (goal setting, eating rules, using support and monitoring) brings you closer to a diet you are less likely to give up on.

1. Start with small goals

Big goals like “−10 kg in 3 months” lead to giving up.
Build up achievable goals, such as “halve my snacking in one week.”

2. Make your eating rules clear

Setting rules like the following according to your constitution reduces uncertainty.

  • If you are poor at metabolizing carbohydrates: cut back on staple foods at dinner
  • If you have low muscle mass: eat protein at every meal

3. Make use of support

Getting guidance from a registered dietitian or trainer makes it easier to stay motivated.

4. Make monitoring a habit

  • Record weight and body fat percentage
  • Log what you eat
  • Check how long you sleep

Recording how your numbers change lets you notice even small changes early, making it easier to fine-tune your plan.

Apps and tools that help with weight loss

Using an app to record your meals and activity makes it easier to look back objectively on whether you are following rules suited to your constitution. Typical apps include the following.

  • Asken
    Records calories, PFC balance and weight
  • MyFitnessPal
    Extensive nutrition data
  • Fitbit
    Measures activity and sleep data
Apps

The ideal balance of medical weight loss and training: how to lose weight efficiently without losing muscle

Medical weight loss (medical diet) is a safe and effective weight-loss progra...

Sample meal plans by constitution

Changing how you choose ingredients according to your constitution type makes it easier to build eating habits that suit you without forcing yourself to hold back. Here we present a model daily menu for each constitution type.
*Portion sizes are a guide. Adjust according to your build and activity level.

A. For people with a low basal metabolism

Goals
– Increase muscle mass and boost metabolism
– Improve sensitivity to cold and swelling

Breakfast

  • Warm miso soup (with ginger)
  • Japanese rolled omelet
  • Brown rice ball
  • Roasted green tea (hojicha)

Lunch

  • Sautéed chicken breast
  • Multigrain rice
  • Steamed broccoli and carrots
  • Tofu

Dinner

  • Salt-grilled mackerel
  • Stir-fried komatsuna greens and mushrooms
  • Simmered kabocha squash

B. For people who are poor at metabolizing carbohydrates

Goals
– Prevent blood sugar spikes
– Improve insulin resistance

Breakfast

  • Ready-to-eat chicken breast
  • Avocado and tomato salad
  • Greek yogurt

Lunch

  • Small serving of multigrain rice
  • Tofu hamburger steak
  • Blanched leafy greens (ohitashi)

Dinner

  • Steamed white fish
  • Vegetable soup
  • Natto

C. For people with low muscle mass

Goals
– Promote muscle protein synthesis
– Prevent energy shortfall

Breakfast

  • Protein drink
  • Whole-wheat bread
  • Boiled egg

Lunch

  • Stir-fried chicken breast and bell pepper
  • Multigrain rice
  • Miso soup with wakame seaweed

Dinner

  • Sautéed beef fillet
  • Simmered hijiki seaweed and edamame
  • Salad

D. For people prone to stress-related weight gain

Goals
– Stabilize blood sugar
– Reduce stress hormones

Breakfast

  • Oatmeal
  • Nuts
  • Soy milk smoothie

Lunch

  • Canned mackerel salad bowl
  • Whole-wheat bread

Dinner

  • Tofu steak
  • Spinach with sesame dressing
  • Miso soup

Not sure if it suits you? Start with a consultation.

A doctor decides whether you can use it and which dose is appropriate, based on your consultation and questionnaire.

No consultation fee (first & follow-up visits)Online consultation available

Recommended exercise by constitution

As with diet, the key to keeping up exercise is adjusting the type and intensity to suit your constitution. Let’s look at the key points and concrete examples for each constitution type.

Low-metabolism type

Key points

  • Prioritize strength training, not just aerobic exercise
  • Improve circulation with morning stretches

Example

  • Twice a week: squats, planks, hip lifts
  • Every day: 20 minutes of walking

Poor carbohydrate metabolism type

Key points

  • Strength training + interval training
  • Light exercise after meals to curb blood sugar rises

Example

  • 3 times a week: circuit training
  • After every meal: 10-minute walk

Low-muscle-mass type

Key points

  • Program centered on strength training
  • Increase the load for each body part

Example

  • 3 times a week: strength training focused on the lower body
  • Once a week: yoga or Pilates to improve flexibility

Prone to stress-related weight gain

Key points

  • Focus on relaxation rather than exercise intensity
  • Combine with breathing techniques or meditation

Example

  • Twice a week: relaxing yoga
  • 3 times a week: stretching + light jogging

Self-monitoring methods for keeping it up

The biggest enemy of dieting is “loss of motivation,” and the habit of recording three things (body composition, meals, and sleep and mood) helps you notice changes and stay motivated. Make the following three kinds of monitoring a habit.

1. Weekly body composition check

  • Weight
  • Body fat percentage
  • Muscle mass

Visualizing how your numbers change gives you a sense of achievement.

2. Food records

Record your daily meals in a notebook or app.
The habit of looking back on whether you are following rules suited to your constitution is important.

3. Recording sleep and mood

Stress and lack of sleep have a big impact on your constitution.
To prevent the vicious circle of “lack of sleep → increased appetite → weight gain,” check your mood as well.

About self-pay treatment and off-label use

Self-pay treatment
Medical weight loss is self-pay treatment (paid in full by the patient) and is not covered by public health insurance.
Off-label use
Using medicines for weight management or weight loss may be off-label use, outside the indications approved in Japan.
Relief System for Adverse Drug Reactions
With off-label use, health damage such as a serious side effect may not be covered by Japan’s Relief System for Adverse Drug Reactions.
Individual differences and the doctor’s judgment
Effects and side effects vary from person to person. A doctor decides after a consultation whether you can use a medicine and which medicine and dose are appropriate. Please tell us in advance about any symptoms, chronic conditions or medicines you are taking.

Frequently asked questions (Q&A)

Here are questions we are often asked during consultations about diets tailored to your constitution.

QCan I lose weight without exercise if the diet suits my constitution?
A

You can lose weight by adjusting your diet alone, but you are more likely to lose muscle mass and your basal metabolism is more likely to drop. Combining it with light exercise suited to your constitution makes rebound less likely.

QDoes my constitution stay the same for life?
A

Your constitution changes with factors such as muscle mass, gut environment and hormonal balance. Women in particular experience major changes across life stages (pregnancy, menopause, etc.), so review it regularly.

QDoes carbohydrate restriction work for everyone?
A

It is effective for people who are poor at metabolizing carbohydrates, but for people with a low basal metabolism or a tendency to stress-eat it can be counterproductive. It needs to be adjusted individually.

QI’m not sure what my constitution type is. How can I find out?
A

You can get a rough idea of your tendencies by checking your basal metabolism and muscle mass with a body composition monitor, and from everyday physical signs such as sleepiness after meals, sensitivity to cold and swelling. If you want to know more, you can also check your metabolic and constitutional tendencies through a medical interview and blood tests at a medical facility.

QWhat should I do if I don’t lose weight even after tailoring my diet to my constitution?
A

In some cases, reviewing lifestyle habits alone is not enough to change your weight. In that case, after consulting a doctor, you can consider options including medical weight loss (treatment using GLP-1 receptor agonists and similar drugs). Because this is self-pay treatment, it is important to make your decision after receiving a thorough explanation of the effects and costs in advance.

Advice from a specialist

The most important thing in keeping up a diet suited to your constitution is not using your constitution as an excuse and not demanding perfection. Finally, here are some points we would like you to keep in mind as your mindset.

  1. Don’t use your constitution as an excuse
    Rather than deciding “I can’t lose weight because of my constitution,” it is important to change how you approach it.
  2. Don’t aim for perfection from the start
    Small steps add up to results.
  3. Don’t expect answers in a short time
    Improving your constitution and losing weight require a perspective of at least 3–6 months.
  4. Consult a trusted specialist
    Getting help from a registered dietitian, doctor or trainer improves your chances of success.

Summary

Understanding your constitution and choosing a method that suits you is the most reliable shortcut to a successful diet you can keep up without strain. A diet that ignores your constitution may reduce your weight temporarily, but it makes rebound more likely and can harm your health.

Understanding your own “constitution,” such as your metabolism, ability to process carbohydrates, muscle mass and stress tolerance, and choosing a method that suits it, is the key to a successful diet you can keep up without strain. Results vary from person to person, so rather than relying on your own judgment about anything that worries you, proceed while consulting a doctor or registered dietitian. Having advised many people, my sense is that those who start after understanding their constitution tend to be less likely to give up along the way.

Use this article as a reference to find the plan that suits you best and achieve healthy weight loss.

Reference links

  1. The glycemic index and metabolic health
  2. Physical activity and resting metabolic rate
  3. Stress, eating behavior, and obesity

Medically reviewed by: Dr. Hiroko Oka (Chairman, Medical Corporation Fukubikai / Certified Member, Japanese Society of Internal Medicine)

*This article is intended to provide general information, and results vary from person to person. If you have health concerns or are considering medical weight loss, do not rely on your own judgment; consult a doctor. Medical weight loss is self-pay treatment (not covered by health insurance).

Reviewing doctor: Hiroko Oka
Reviewing doctor

Hiroko OkaDirector, Hiro Clinic Kawaguchi (physician)

Japanese Society of Internal Medicine About our medical review and editorial policy

You may also like

Back to all articles

Ask our AI chat AI chat