Is a low-carb diet safe? How to do it properly: a doctor’s tips for losing weight efficiently while keeping risks low

  • Published:
  • Written by the Hiro Clinic Medical Weight Loss editorial team
  • 36 min read
Medically reviewed by Dr. Hiroko Oka Reviewed byDr. Hiroko OkaCertified Member, Japanese Society of Internal Medicine Editorial policy
Is a low-carb diet safe? How to do it properly: a doctor’s tips for losing weight efficiently while keeping risks low

A low-carb diet is a method that carries a risk of making you unwell if you do not approach it with the right knowledge. While it is widely known as a way to lose weight relatively quickly, many people also search for “is a low-carb diet dangerous,” and there are reported cases of people harming their health by trying it without properly understanding the risks and downsides. In our clinic, too, I have seen patients come in feeling unwell after cutting carbohydrates to extreme levels on their own. In this article, I explain the effects and risks of a low-carb diet and the key points for doing it safely, drawing on research from Japan and abroad and on expert opinion.

Key points firstShort on time? Just read this

  • A low-carb diet is a method that carries a risk of making you unwell if you do not approach it with the right knowledge
  • If you cut out carbohydrates almost entirely, you are more likely to run short of important nutrients such as B vitamins, dietary fiber and minerals
  • Rather than cutting carbs drastically, it is considered better to start by adjusting to around 150 g of carbohydrate a day and let your body adapt gradually

What is a low-carb diet?

A low-carb diet is a dietary approach that reduces carbohydrate (sugar and starch) intake and uses fat and protein as the main sources of energy. Cutting back on carbohydrates is said to prevent sharp rises in blood sugar, reduce insulin secretion and limit fat storage.
The Atkins diet and the ketogenic diet are also types of low-carb diet.

Possible benefits of a low-carb diet

Several studies have suggested that carbohydrate restriction may have the following effects.

Risks and downsides of a low-carb diet

A low-carb diet done the wrong way or taken to extremes can cause serious harm to your health. Here are the main risks.

1. Unbalanced nutrition

If you cut out carbohydrates almost entirely, you are more likely to run short of important nutrients such as B vitamins, dietary fiber and minerals. In particular, drastically cutting back on vegetables and whole grains can make constipation, skin problems and fatigue worse.

2. Feeling unwell due to ketosis

When extreme carbohydrate restriction shifts the body into “ketosis” (a state in which fat is used as the energy source), it can be accompanied by nausea, headache, fatigue, and bad breath or body odor (a ketone smell). On social media, @s_matuzaki explains that “when you cut carbs a lot, the body burns fat and makes ketone bodies. If you are also eating too little or are short of iron or B vitamins, your cells can’t use them up properly, so they are more easily released through your breath and sweat.” This is a useful reminder not to dismiss it as ordinary sweat odor, but to treat it as a sign that your body is changing.

3. Loss of muscle mass

Carbohydrates play an essential role in maintaining muscle. If insufficient energy intake or a lack of protein continues, muscle breakdown progresses and your basal metabolism falls.

4. Cardiovascular risk

On a low-carb diet, fat intake tends to increase, and excessive intake of saturated fat may lead to atherosclerosis and higher LDL cholesterol.
A large Swedish study published in 2010 reported that a low-carbohydrate, high-protein diet tended to increase the risk of cardiovascular disease over the long term.
Reference: Low carbohydrate-high protein diet and incidence of cardiovascular diseases in Swedish women

5. Effects during pregnancy and breastfeeding

Extreme carbohydrate restriction during pregnancy or breastfeeding may harm the growth of the fetus or baby, and experts do not recommend it.

The complete guide to snacks while dieting: how to choose snacks that won’t make you gain weight, when to eat them and recommended types

Are you convinced that “I’m on a diet, so I have to give up snack...

Key points for doing a low-carb diet safely and successfully

Done correctly, carbohydrate restriction may offer some health benefits, but you need to keep the following points in mind.

1. Start with a moderate reduction in carbs

Rather than cutting carbs drastically, it is considered better to start by adjusting to around 150 g of carbohydrate a day and let your body adapt gradually.

2. Choose good-quality fats and proteins

If you increase your fat intake, focus on omega-3 fatty acids (oily fish, flaxseed oil) and unsaturated fats (olive oil, nuts), and keep saturated fat to a minimum.

3. Pay attention to fiber and vitamins

Even while limiting carbohydrates, it is essential to get enough dietary fiber, vitamins and minerals from foods such as green and yellow vegetables, seaweed and mushrooms.

4. Talk to a doctor or dietitian

In particular, if you have an existing condition such as diabetes, high blood pressure or dyslipidemia, be sure to plan your diet in consultation with a healthcare professional.

5. Combine it with moderate exercise

To maintain muscle mass and prevent a drop in basal metabolism, make strength training or walking a habit.

Woman exercising

Recent research on low-carb diets

There is a wide range of research on the effectiveness and risks of carbohydrate restriction. Here are some representative findings.

Foods suited to a low-carb diet and foods to avoid

Food choice is very important for a successful low-carb diet. Simply “cutting out carbs” can harm your health, so you need to make an effort to keep your nutrition properly balanced.

Foods to include

Protein sources

  • Chicken breast, chicken tenderloin
  • Eggs
  • Soy products (natto, tofu)
  • Fish and seafood

Sources of good-quality fat

  • Olive oil
  • Avocado
  • Nuts
  • Oily fish (containing EPA and DHA)

Low-carb, nutrient-rich vegetables

  • Broccoli
  • Spinach
  • Cauliflower
  • Bell peppers
  • Mushrooms

Fermented foods

  • Kimchi
  • Miso
  • Yogurt (unsweetened)

Foods to limit or be careful with

High-carbohydrate foods

  • Refined grains such as white rice, bread and udon noodles
  • Potatoes and sweet potatoes
  • Sweet snacks and desserts

Processed foods

  • Sausages and bacon (high in additives and saturated fat)
  • Soft drinks

On a low-carb diet, people often mistakenly assume that “low-carb food = healthy,” but highly processed foods can easily lead to excessive fat and salt intake, so be careful.

Low-carb diets and brain function

The brain relies mainly on glucose for energy. As a result, extreme carbohydrate restriction can temporarily cause poor concentration, irritability and fatigue.

Clinical reports show that the following symptoms are known to occur during the transition to ketosis.

  • Slower thinking
  • Mood swings
  • Difficulty paying attention

However, symptoms may ease over time as ketone bodies become an alternative energy source for the brain.
Reference: Ketone bodies as a therapeutic for neuropsychiatric diseases

Effects of a low-carb diet on the gut environment

Reducing carbohydrates also reduces your intake of dietary fiber and fermentable carbohydrates (oligosaccharides), raising concerns that the diversity of your gut bacteria (microbiota) may decline.

A worsening gut environment can cause

  • constipation
  • skin problems
  • chronic inflammation

and various other health problems.

Recent research has reported that extreme carbohydrate restriction may have a negative effect on the balance of gut bacteria.
Reference: Impact of the ketogenic diet on gut microbiota

Not sure if it suits you? Start with a consultation.

A doctor decides whether you can use it and which dose is appropriate, based on your consultation and questionnaire.

No consultation fee (first & follow-up visits)Online consultation available

Steps and practical tips for a low-carb diet

To make your low-carb diet a success, follow these steps.

Step 1: Set your goals

  • Be clear whether your aim is weight loss or blood sugar control
  • Set a specific target weight and time frame
  • Make a habit of keeping a food diary

Step 2: Cut carbs gradually

  • Instead of suddenly dropping to 20 g or less a day, start by halving your portion of staple foods (rice, bread, noodles)
  • Once you are used to it, adjust your carbohydrate intake to around 100 g

Step 3: Add protein and good-quality fats

  • Prevent an energy shortfall from eating fewer staple foods
  • Aim for about 20–30 g of protein at each meal

Step 4: Check your nutritional status regularly

  • Check not only your weight and body fat but also blood test results and bowel habits
  • Proceed in consultation with a professional

Common misconceptions about low-carb diets and the facts

There are many misconceptions about carbohydrate restriction. Here are some typical examples.

Misconception 1: The closer you get to zero carbs, the more weight you lose

→ It often causes an energy shortfall and a slower metabolism, which can actually stall weight loss.

Misconception 2: You should stay low-carb for life

→ After losing weight in the short term, a “carb refeed” or “cycling method” that returns to a moderate carbohydrate intake is sometimes recommended.

Misconception 3: A low-carb diet suits everyone

→ If you have an existing condition such as diabetes, liver disease or reduced kidney function, restrictions are needed. It is also not suitable during pregnancy or breastfeeding, or for growing children.

Doctor

How to decide whether a low-carb diet is right for you

When considering carbohydrate restriction, it is important to ask yourself the following.

  • Does it fit well with your eating habits and preferences?
  • Will your family and those around you understand and support it?
  • Can you restrict carbs within a range you can keep up?
  • Can you get support from a doctor or registered dietitian?

Success stories and points to note

Quite a few people have adopted carbohydrate restriction and succeeded in losing weight or controlling their blood sugar. On the other hand, there are also reports of metabolic disorders and cardiovascular risks emerging when restriction continued for a long time.

Success example:

  • Man in his 40s: with prediabetes, he followed a low-carb diet for one year and his HbA1c improved from 6.7% to 5.9%. Under a doctor’s guidance, he successfully reintroduced carbohydrates gradually.

Failure example:

  • Woman in her 30s: restricted carbohydrates to 20 g or less on her own and developed fatigue, irregular periods and dyslipidemia.

As these examples show, results vary greatly from person to person. From my impression following patients in practice, too, those who progressed step by step under a doctor’s supervision were less likely to become unwell, while those who rushed on their own were more likely to show signs of feeling unwell.

Low-carb diets compared with other diets

Some studies suggest that a low-carb diet produces greater short-term weight loss than other approaches such as calorie restriction or the Mediterranean diet, but its long-term safety is still being debated.

  • Compared with calorie restriction:
    • Low-carb diets tend to produce slightly greater weight loss over about 6 months.
    • After 12 months, the difference narrows.
  • Compared with the Mediterranean diet:
    • Some reports suggest the Mediterranean diet is better for blood sugar and lipid control.

Comparison of Weight-Loss Diets with Different Compositions of Fat, Protein, and Carbohydrates

About self-pay treatment and off-label use

Self-pay treatment
Medical weight loss is self-pay treatment (paid in full by the patient) and is not covered by public health insurance.
Off-label use
Using medicines for weight management or weight loss may be off-label use, outside the indications approved in Japan.
Relief System for Adverse Drug Reactions
With off-label use, health damage such as a serious side effect may not be covered by Japan’s Relief System for Adverse Drug Reactions.
Individual differences and the doctor’s judgment
Effects and side effects vary from person to person. A doctor decides after a consultation whether you can use a medicine and which medicine and dose are appropriate. Please tell us in advance about any symptoms, chronic conditions or medicines you are taking.

FAQ

QIs a low-carb diet dangerous?
A

A low-carb diet is a method that carries a risk of making you unwell if you do not approach it with the right knowledge.

QWhat nutritional problems can extreme carb cutting cause?
A

If you cut out carbohydrates almost entirely, you are more likely to run short of important nutrients such as B vitamins, dietary fiber and minerals.

QWhat symptoms can ketosis cause?
A

When extreme carbohydrate restriction shifts the body into “ketosis” (a state in which fat is used as the energy source), it can be accompanied by nausea, headache, fatigue, and bad breath or body odor (a ketone smell).

QWhere should I start with a low-carb diet?
A

Rather than cutting carbs drastically, it is considered better to start by adjusting to around 150 g of carbohydrate a day and let your body adapt gradually.

QIs it OK to follow a low-carb diet while pregnant or breastfeeding?
A

Extreme carbohydrate restriction during pregnancy or breastfeeding may harm the growth of the fetus or baby, and experts do not recommend it.

Summary: reduce the risks with the right knowledge and restrict carbs safely

Behind the attention given to the phrase “low-carb diet dangerous” is a tendency to focus so much on short-term weight loss that health risks are overlooked.

As explained in this column,

  • extreme carbohydrate restriction carries significant risks
  • combine moderate restriction with good-quality nutrition
  • get guidance from a doctor or registered dietitian

Following these points is the key to keeping a low-carb diet safe and sustainable.

Choose a method that suits your constitution and lifestyle, and work toward healthy goals without overdoing it.

List of references

  1. Dietary carbohydrate restriction as the first approach in diabetes management
  2. Effects of low-carbohydrate diets versus low-fat diets on metabolic risk factors
  3. Low carbohydrate-high protein diet and incidence of cardiovascular diseases in Swedish women
  4. Low carbohydrate diet and all cause and cause specific mortality: prospective cohort study
Reviewing doctor: Hiroko Oka
Reviewing doctor

Hiroko OkaDirector, Hiro Clinic Kawaguchi (physician)

Japanese Society of Internal Medicine Chair, Fukubikai Medical Corporation / Certified Member, Japanese Society of Internal Medicine Graduated from Toho University School of Medicine and joined the Department of Internal Medicine at Keio University School of Medicine. After training in internal medicine at university and general hospitals, she has worked in obesity treatment and weight-management guidance from an internal-medicine perspective. About our medical review and editorial policy

You may also like

Back to all articles

Last updated:

Ask our AI chat AI chat