Is genetic testing for weight loss pointless? A doctor explains reliability, cost and how to choose

  • Published:
  • Updated:
  • Written by the Hiro Clinic Medical Weight Loss editorial team
  • 47 min read
Medically reviewed by Dr. Hiroko Oka Reviewed byDr. Hiroko OkaCertified Member, Japanese Society of Internal Medicine Editorial policy
Is genetic testing for weight loss pointless? A doctor explains reliability, cost and how to choose

Using genetic testing for weight loss can show you your “genetic tendencies” related to how easily you gain weight, appetite, energy expenditure and similar traits. However, a test alone cannot determine a “guaranteed way to lose weight” or “the best diet for you.” Body weight is influenced by many factors, including diet, exercise, sleep, age, illness and medications, so it is important to use the results as hints for reviewing your lifestyle habits.

What you will learn in this article

  • What a diet genetic test shows is some genotypes related to obesity and statistical tendencies.
  • The test is not “meaningless,” but it does not guarantee weight loss or the best diet for you.
  • In a large comparative trial, the genotypes tested could not predict whether a person would lose more weight on a low-fat diet or a low-carbohydrate diet.
  • To judge reliability, check the genes tested, the scientific evidence, the analysis setup, whether explanations are provided and how personal information is handled.
  • Do not use the results to justify extreme dietary restrictions; combine them with how your body actually responds, such as weight and food records.

What is a diet genetic test, and what can it tell you?

What is a diet genetic test?

  1. 1

    The test

    DNA from saliva or cheek cells

    Usually analyzes SNPs

    Genes linked to obesity and appetite

  2. 2

    What it shows

    Tendencies of specific genotypes

    Associations reported in research

  3. 3

    What it does not show

    Current body fat percentage or metabolic rate

    Diagnosis of diabetes

FTO, MC4R, ADRB3, UCP1, etc.

A diet genetic test collects DNA from saliva, cheek cells or similar samples and examines some of the genes reported to be associated with obesity, appetite and energy metabolism. Many services analyze SNPs (single nucleotide polymorphisms, pronounced “snips”), which are individual differences in the DNA sequence.

What the results tell you is “what tendencies have been reported in groups of people with a particular genotype.” The test does not directly diagnose your current body fat percentage, basal metabolic rate or whether you have diabetes.

Main genesMain functions and associations studiedPoints to note when reading results
FTOAssociations with BMI, obesity and appetiteHaving it does not mean you will definitely become obese
MC4RAssociations with appetite and energy balanceCommon variants must be distinguished from rare, medically important mutations
ADRB3Associations with fat breakdown in fat cells and energy expenditureResults may not be consistent depending on the population studied
UCP1Associations with heat production in brown adipose tissueNo single gene determines energy expenditure

The genes and SNPs examined differ from service to service. The Hiro Clinic genetic testing site describes in detail the main SNPs examined in diet genetic tests.

Is diet genetic testing pointless? Our conclusion on reliability

Reliability of genetic testing

  1. 1

    Conclusion

    A prompt to review your habits

    Following the results guarantees weight loss

    Evidence is insufficient

  2. 2

    Trials and research

    DIETFITS trial, 609 people

    Did not predict response to diets

    No difference in response by FTO type

  3. 3

    Limitations

    78% of reviewed subjects were of European ancestry

    Validation in Japanese people is also needed

    Not a substitute for diagnosis

Key points

In short, genetic testing can be used to better understand your constitution and as a prompt to review your behavior. However, there is not enough evidence that eating according to your test results will definitely lead to weight loss.

In the DIETFITS trial, which compared a low-fat diet with a low-carbohydrate diet in 609 people, weight change after 12 months varied between individuals, but the genetic patterns examined could not be said to predict “which diet would lead to more weight loss.” In addition, a study analyzing eight randomized controlled trials with a total of 9,563 people did not show that FTO genotype significantly changed the response to weight-loss interventions such as diet and exercise.

A 2024 systematic review found that, while some studies showed effects of gene–diet combinations on body weight, the results were inconsistent, and 78% of subjects were from populations of European ancestry. Validation in diverse populations, including Japanese people, is also needed. At present, genetic testing does not replace a doctor’s diagnosis or actual measurements of weight, waist circumference, blood tests and food records.

What genetic testing can and cannot tell you

Can tell you

  • The genotypes tested and the tendencies reported in research

Cannot tell you

  • Whether you will definitely gain weight, how many kg you will lose, or whether a specific diet or medication will work best for you

In other words, it is not appropriate either to dismiss testing as “pointless” or to think that “genes alone determine the right answer.” The realistic approach is to use it as supplementary information for choosing behaviors you can sustain comfortably, while considering both genetic factors and your living environment.

Do not decide on carbohydrate or fat restriction based on results alone

Do not choose your diet from results alone

  1. 1

    Decisions to avoid

    Cutting carbs drastically because of your type

    Avoiding fat across the board because of your type

  2. 2

    What to check

    Record weight, waist and meals

    Check how your body actually responds

    Do not turn results into a banned-food list

  3. 3

    How to proceed

    Start with snacks, alcohol and portion size

    1–2 behaviors that are easy to improve

    See a doctor if you have a chronic condition or take medication

Commercial tests sometimes present easy-to-understand categories such as “type that gains weight from carbohydrates” or “type that gains weight from fat.” However, in most cases these are tendencies based on a limited number of genetic variants. We do not recommend decisions such as drastically cutting carbohydrates because you have a certain FTO type, or avoiding fat across the board because of your ADRB3 type.

  • Do not turn your results into a “list of banned foods”
  • Record your weight, waist circumference, meals, activity level and sleep to check how your body actually responds
  • First, choose 1–2 behaviors that are easy to improve, such as snacking, alcohol or portion size
  • If you have a chronic condition or take medication, consult a doctor before starting any extreme dietary restriction

If you would like to consider an approach that takes into account not only your constitution but also your lifestyle, see also how to choose medical weight loss that suits your constitution.

Differences between genetic test kits and tests at a medical facility

Kits vs. tests at a medical facility

  1. 1

    Commercial / mail-in

    Order at home, collect your own sample

    Results via web, app or booklet

    Consultation depends on the service

  2. 2

    Medical facilities, etc.

    Explanation and sample collection on site in some cases

    You may be able to consult a doctor

    Varies by what is offered

  3. 3

    Points to check

    Collection and analysis methods, evidence

    Data storage and secondary use

    Who explains, consultation, cost

A hospital test is not necessarily more accurate

ItemCommercial mail-in kitsTests at medical facilities, etc.
Ordering and sample collectionMostly ordered at home, with saliva or cheek cells collected by yourselfSome involve receiving an explanation and having the sample collected on site
Explanation of resultsMostly via web, app or booklet. Whether consultation is available varies by serviceYou may be able to consult a doctor or staff member
PurposeReference for constitutional tendencies and lifestyle improvementVaries by what is offered. Weight-related tests may not be for diagnostic purposes
Points to checkCollection and analysis methods, evidence, data storage and secondary useWho explains the results, post-test consultation, cost, distinction from medical care

It cannot be said across the board that “a test at a hospital is always more accurate” or that “all commercial kits are dubious.” Look not only at where you take the test, but also at what is tested, the analysis setup, the scientific evidence and the support available for explanations and consultation. Consumer materials from Japan’s Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry also recommend checking the purpose and limitations of the test, analytical accuracy, scientific evidence, collaboration with medical institutions and the handling of personal information.

Downsides and cautions of diet genetic testing

Cautions about genetic testing

  1. 1

    Reading the results

    Easy to over-trust results

    Results differ by service

    Different genes and criteria

  2. 2

    Diet and cost

    Extreme restriction causes nutritional imbalance

    Testing alone does not cause weight loss

    Check subscriptions and extra fees

  3. 3

    Data management

    Check storage and research use

    Third-party sharing and overseas transfer

    Deletion terms after cancellation

See a medical facility for sudden weight gain, etc.

It is easy to over-trust the results

A small number of genes cannot pinpoint the cause of weight gain or the best diet for you.

Results may differ between services

This is because the genes examined, the research referenced and the criteria used differ.

It can lead to extreme dietary restriction

Avoiding foods based only on labels like “carb type” or “fat type” may lead to an unbalanced diet.

The handling of genetic information needs to be checked

Before applying, check how samples and data are stored, research use, third-party sharing, overseas transfer and the conditions for deletion after you cancel.

Paying for a test alone will not make you lose weight

What matters is how you apply the results to your daily life and keep it up. Also check the cost of subscriptions and additional consultations.

If your weight gain is sudden, you have severe fatigue or swelling, you have menstrual irregularities, or you are worried about diabetes or thyroid disease, do not rely on a genetic test alone; consult a medical facility.

Cost of diet genetic tests and time to results

Commercial diet genetic test kits mostly cost from several thousand yen to the ¥10,000s. The price varies with the number of genes tested, the content of the results report, consultations with registered dietitians or others, and the length of app access. Time to results also ranges from a few days to about one month, so do not choose on price alone; compare the test content and support as well. Prices and terms may change, so check each service’s official information before applying.

Not sure if it suits you? Start with a consultation.

A doctor decides whether you can use it and which dose is appropriate, based on your consultation and questionnaire.

No consultation fee (first & follow-up visits)Online consultation available

How to choose a reliable diet genetic test

  • Are the genes and SNPs tested clearly stated?
    Check not only “how many types are tested” but also their names and what the results mean.
  • Is the basis for the assessment shown?
    Ideally, choose a service where you can check the papers or official materials, including the ethnicity, number of people and research methods involved.
  • Are the analysis and quality-control systems explained?
    Check measures against sample mix-ups, analysis methods, conditions for retesting and so on.
  • Are the limitations of the results stated?
    Be careful of definitive claims about results such as “you will definitely lose weight” or “find out your ideal diet.”
  • Is there someone to consult?
    If you are concerned about your results, check whether you can consult a doctor, genetic counselor, registered dietitian or similar professional.
  • Is the handling of personal information and samples clear?
    Check the storage period, disposal method, secondary use for research or advertising, third-party sharing and how to withdraw consent.
  • Are the total cost and time to results clear?
    Also check for additional fees, cancellation and refund terms and ongoing app fees.

Hiro Clinic’s diet genetic test

As a perk for people who register with us on LINE, Hiro Clinic offers a diet genetic test taken at the clinic. Please avoid eating and drinking for 30 minutes before the test; results are sent by email after about one month. Rather than deciding on treatment based on genetic test results alone, it is important to also consider your diet, exercise and lifestyle. For eligibility and terms, please check the latest information on LINE registration perks.

If you would like to learn the basics of genes related to obesity, see also Hiro Clinic genetic testing’s explanation of obesity genes and constitution types.

If you would like to consult a doctor about weight management

*This is self-pay treatment. Depending on the results of the consultation, you may not be able to receive the treatment you want.

3 steps to using test results for weight loss

  1. Read the results as “tendencies”

    Having a risk type does not determine your current weight or future obesity. Conversely, even with a “standard type,” your weight can increase depending on your diet and activity level. First, check which genes were tested, the basis for the assessment and the limitations of the results.

  2. Choose 1–2 behaviors that are easy to change

    Start with behaviors you can keep up, such as recording your snacks, eating a balanced meal with a staple, main dish and side dishes, walking more, and getting enough sleep. Regardless of genotype, the long-term balance between energy intake and energy expenditure is important for weight management.

  3. Adjust based on actual changes

    Record your weight, waist circumference, meals, activity level and sleep each week. If there is no change after 2–4 weeks, if you experience strong hunger or feel unwell, or if a chronic condition or medication may be having an effect, consult a doctor or registered dietitian.

About self-pay treatment and off-label use

Self-pay treatment
Medical weight loss is self-pay treatment (paid in full by the patient) and is not covered by public health insurance.
Off-label use
Using medicines for weight management or weight loss may be off-label use, outside the indications approved in Japan.
Relief System for Adverse Drug Reactions
With off-label use, health damage such as a serious side effect may not be covered by Japan’s Relief System for Adverse Drug Reactions.
Individual differences and the doctor’s judgment
Effects and side effects vary from person to person. A doctor decides after a consultation whether you can use a medicine and which medicine and dose are appropriate. Please tell us in advance about any symptoms, chronic conditions or medicines you are taking.

Frequently asked questions about diet genetic testing

QWhat can genetic testing tell me about weight loss?
A

It shows the genotypes tested and their statistical associations with obesity, appetite, energy metabolism and so on. It is not a test that directly measures your current metabolic rate or identifies a diet that will definitely make you lose weight.

QIs it true that diet genetic testing is pointless or dubious?
A

Because the test will not necessarily make you lose weight, advertising that guarantees results should be viewed with caution. On the other hand, it can be used to learn about your tendencies and as a prompt to review your behavior. Check whether the scientific evidence and limitations of the test are clearly stated.

QWill I lose weight if I take a genetic test?
A

The test itself has no weight-loss effect. What matters is how you change your diet, exercise, sleep and so on after the test, and whether you keep it up. At present, there is also not enough evidence that a diet matched to your genotype leads to more weight loss than an ordinary healthy diet.

QHow much does a diet genetic test cost?
A

Commercial kits mostly cost from several thousand yen to the ¥10,000s, but this varies with the tests included and consultation support. Compare them including additional fees, explanations of results and how personal information is managed.

QCan genetic testing tell me which foods make me gain weight?
A

It may show genetic tendencies said to be related to how you respond to carbohydrates or fats, but it cannot determine that eating a specific food will definitely make you gain weight. Your response also changes with portion size, cooking methods, activity level, sleep, medications and other factors. Combine your test results with food records, and adjust while watching actual changes rather than cutting out foods drastically.

QHow long does it take to get the results?
A

It ranges from a few days to about one month depending on the service. At Hiro Clinic, results are sent by email after about one month.

QIs it enough to take a genetic test once?
A

The DNA sequence you are born with basically does not change, so there is usually little need to test the same genes repeatedly. However, as research progresses, the interpretation of the same results and the recommendations may be updated.

QCan a diet genetic test diagnose a disease?
A

Diet genetic tests for the general public are usually not intended to diagnose disease. If you are worried about diabetes, thyroid disease or similar conditions, do not rely on a test kit’s assessment alone; see a medical facility.

QI am worried about my genetic information being leaked. What should I check?
A

In the privacy policy, check the storage period for samples and data, disposal methods, third-party sharing, secondary use for research or product development, and the procedures for withdrawing consent or requesting deletion. If anything is unclear, contact the provider before applying.

Not sure? Talk to us

No consultation fee (first & follow-up visits)Online consultation available

Toll-free 0120-241-929 (toll-free in Japan, 9:00–18:00 JST, Japanese only)

See prices

Summary: genetic testing is not “the answer” but material for thinking about your constitution

A diet genetic test is one way to learn about genetic tendencies related to obesity. However, the results alone do not determine the best diet for you or how much weight you will lose. Choose a reliable test and use the results in combination with your current lifestyle habits and records. It is important to consult a doctor about why you are not losing weight, any chronic conditions, and treatment options.

References and official materials

Reviewing doctor: Hiroko Oka
Reviewing doctor

Hiroko OkaDirector, Hiro Clinic Kawaguchi (physician)

Japanese Society of Internal Medicine Chairman, Medical Corporation Fukubikai / Certified Member, Japanese Society of Internal Medicine After graduating from Toho University School of Medicine in 1997, joined the Department of Internal Medicine at Keio University School of Medicine. Gained extensive experience in internal medicine at university and general hospitals, and opened Hiro Clinic in 2008. About our medical review and editorial policy

You may also like

Back to all articles

Ask our AI chat AI chat